Talk:Supramolecular chemistry - Revision history

Smokefoot: Parent: Supramolecular polymer. 50 refs, several >2020. Most of the article written by User:Injp20 in one edit. Their only contribution to Wikipedia.

2024-11-03T16:41:24Z

Parent: Supramolecular polymer. 50 refs, several >2020. Most of the article written by User:Injp20 in one edit. Their only contribution to Wikipedia.

← Previous revision		Revision as of 16:41, 3 November 2024
Line 98:		Line 98:
	***[[Pnictogen bond]]. 10 refs, single author.		***[[Pnictogen bond]]. 10 refs, single author.
	**[[Salt bridge (protein and supramolecular)]]. 26 refs, <2020.		**[[Salt bridge (protein and supramolecular)]]. 26 refs, <2020.
	===Merge into supramolecular polymer===
⚫	Parent: [[Supramolecular polymer]]. 50 refs, several >2020. Most of the article written by User:Injp20 in one edit. Their only contribution to Wikipedia.

	===Merge into [[Macromolecular assembly]]===		===Merge into [[Macromolecular assembly]]===
Line 125:		Line 123:

	===Leave intact===		===Leave intact===
		⚫	*Parent: [[Supramolecular polymer]]. 50 refs, several >2020. Most of the article written by User:Injp20 in one edit. Their only contribution to Wikipedia, bad sign.
	*[[Self-assembled monolayer]] 45 refs, most recent 2012. We cannot merge this one but its interesting to see how this area has ceased to gain editing.		*[[Self-assembled monolayer]] 45 refs, most recent 2012. We cannot merge this one but its interesting to see how this area has ceased to gain editing.
	*[[Two-dimensional polymer]]. 50 refs. Undefined by IUPAC.		*[[Two-dimensional polymer]]. 50 refs. Undefined by IUPAC.

Smokefoot: /* Merge to Host-guest chemistry? */ done

2024-11-03T16:39:34Z

Merge to Host-guest chemistry?: done

← Previous revision		Revision as of 16:39, 3 November 2024
Line 110:		Line 110:
	*[[Host-guest chemistry]] 45, several > 2020. Target of >100 links. Lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. Undefined by IUPAC. ChemRev 10.1021/cr5005315, 10.1021/cr200333h, 10.1021/acs.chemrev.9b00839, 10.1021/cr5006342, 10.1021/cr200213s		*[[Host-guest chemistry]] 45, several > 2020. Target of >100 links. Lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. Undefined by IUPAC. ChemRev 10.1021/cr5005315, 10.1021/cr200333h, 10.1021/acs.chemrev.9b00839, 10.1021/cr5006342, 10.1021/cr200213s
	*[[Inclusion compound]] (also inclusion complex) (5 refs, most recent is 2010). Target of <50 links? How does this topic differ from Host-guest chemistry? Its lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. IUPAC def exists but not mentioned<!-- (A complex in which one component (the host) forms a cavity or, in the case of a crystal, a crystal lattice containing spaces in the shape of long tunnels or channels in which molecular entities of a second chemical species (the guest) are located. There is no covalent bonding between guest and host, the attraction being generally due to van der Waals forces. If the spaces in the host lattice are enclosed on all sides so that the guest species is 'trapped' as in a cage, such compounds are known as clathrates or 'cage compounds'.)--> See "Supramolecular and molecular capsules, cages and containers" 10.1039/D4CS00761A {{done}}		*[[Inclusion compound]] (also inclusion complex) (5 refs, most recent is 2010). Target of <50 links? How does this topic differ from Host-guest chemistry? Its lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. IUPAC def exists but not mentioned<!-- (A complex in which one component (the host) forms a cavity or, in the case of a crystal, a crystal lattice containing spaces in the shape of long tunnels or channels in which molecular entities of a second chemical species (the guest) are located. There is no covalent bonding between guest and host, the attraction being generally due to van der Waals forces. If the spaces in the host lattice are enclosed on all sides so that the guest species is 'trapped' as in a cage, such compounds are known as clathrates or 'cage compounds'.)--> See "Supramolecular and molecular capsules, cages and containers" 10.1039/D4CS00761A {{done}}
	*[[Molecular encapsulation]]. 7 refs. Merge into [[Host-guest chemistry]].		*[[Molecular encapsulation]]. 7 refs. Merge into [[Host-guest chemistry]]. {{done}}
	**[[clathrate]] 12 refs, 2015 vintage. IUPAC def. Usually solids (zeolites, MOFs)		**[[clathrate]] 12 refs, 2015 vintage. IUPAC def. Usually solids (zeolites, MOFs)
	**[[Cavitand]] 8 refs. = cyclodextrins + calixarenes + pillararenes + cucurbiturils.		**[[Cavitand]] 8 refs. = cyclodextrins + calixarenes + pillararenes + cucurbiturils.

Smokefoot: /* Merge to Host-guest chemistry? */ partially done

2024-11-03T16:17:56Z

Merge to Host-guest chemistry?: partially done

← Previous revision		Revision as of 16:17, 3 November 2024
Line 109:		Line 109:
	<!--March "When the reaction of two compounds results in a product that contains all the mass of the two compounds, the product is called an addition compound. There are several kinds. In the rest of this chapter, we will discuss addition compounds in which the molecules of the starting materials remain more or less intact and weak bonds hold two or more molecules together. We can divide them into four broad classes: electron donor–acceptor complexes, complexes formed by crown ethers and similar compounds, inclusion compounds [urea, carcerands, cyclodextrins), and catenanes." March mentions host-guest only once.-->		<!--March "When the reaction of two compounds results in a product that contains all the mass of the two compounds, the product is called an addition compound. There are several kinds. In the rest of this chapter, we will discuss addition compounds in which the molecules of the starting materials remain more or less intact and weak bonds hold two or more molecules together. We can divide them into four broad classes: electron donor–acceptor complexes, complexes formed by crown ethers and similar compounds, inclusion compounds [urea, carcerands, cyclodextrins), and catenanes." March mentions host-guest only once.-->
	*[[Host-guest chemistry]] 45, several > 2020. Target of >100 links. Lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. Undefined by IUPAC. ChemRev 10.1021/cr5005315, 10.1021/cr200333h, 10.1021/acs.chemrev.9b00839, 10.1021/cr5006342, 10.1021/cr200213s		*[[Host-guest chemistry]] 45, several > 2020. Target of >100 links. Lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. Undefined by IUPAC. ChemRev 10.1021/cr5005315, 10.1021/cr200333h, 10.1021/acs.chemrev.9b00839, 10.1021/cr5006342, 10.1021/cr200213s
	*[[Inclusion compound]] (also inclusion complex) (5 refs, most recent is 2010). Target of <50 links? How does this topic differ from Host-guest chemistry? Its lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. IUPAC def exists but not mentioned<!-- (A complex in which one component (the host) forms a cavity or, in the case of a crystal, a crystal lattice containing spaces in the shape of long tunnels or channels in which molecular entities of a second chemical species (the guest) are located. There is no covalent bonding between guest and host, the attraction being generally due to van der Waals forces. If the spaces in the host lattice are enclosed on all sides so that the guest species is 'trapped' as in a cage, such compounds are known as clathrates or 'cage compounds'.)--> See "Supramolecular and molecular capsules, cages and containers" 10.1039/D4CS00761A		*[[Inclusion compound]] (also inclusion complex) (5 refs, most recent is 2010). Target of <50 links? How does this topic differ from Host-guest chemistry? Its lead examples are crowns, calix's, cyclodextrins. IUPAC def exists but not mentioned<!-- (A complex in which one component (the host) forms a cavity or, in the case of a crystal, a crystal lattice containing spaces in the shape of long tunnels or channels in which molecular entities of a second chemical species (the guest) are located. There is no covalent bonding between guest and host, the attraction being generally due to van der Waals forces. If the spaces in the host lattice are enclosed on all sides so that the guest species is 'trapped' as in a cage, such compounds are known as clathrates or 'cage compounds'.)--> See "Supramolecular and molecular capsules, cages and containers" 10.1039/D4CS00761A {{done}}
	*[[Molecular encapsulation]]. 7 refs. Merge into [[Host-guest chemistry]].		*[[Molecular encapsulation]]. 7 refs. Merge into [[Host-guest chemistry]].
	**[[clathrate]] 12 refs, 2015 vintage. IUPAC def. Usually solids (zeolites, MOFs)		**[[clathrate]] 12 refs, 2015 vintage. IUPAC def. Usually solids (zeolites, MOFs)

Smokefoot: /* Merge into Macromolecular assembly / Note that Biomolecular complex had earlier been merged into Macromolecular assembly.

2024-11-03T16:16:52Z

Merge into Macromolecular assembly: *Note that Biomolecular complex had earlier been merged into Macromolecular assembly.

← Previous revision		Revision as of 16:16, 3 November 2024
Line 104:		Line 104:
	*parent: [[Macromolecular assembly]]. 18 refs, mostly 2016ish. Undefined by IUPAC.		*parent: [[Macromolecular assembly]]. 18 refs, mostly 2016ish. Undefined by IUPAC.
	*[[Macromolecular cages]]. 11 refs. Pure homework assignment. Merge or redirect.<!--{{cite journal \|last1=Ahmad \|first1=Nazir \|last2=Younus \|first2=Hossein A. \|last3=Chughtai \|first3=Adeel H. \|last4=Verport \|first4=Francis \|title=Metal-organic molecular cages: applications of biochemical implications \|journal=Chemical Society Reviews \|date=2015 \|volume=44 \|issue=1 \|pages=9–25 \|doi=10.1039/C4CS00222A \|pmid=25319756 }}-->		*[[Macromolecular cages]]. 11 refs. Pure homework assignment. Merge or redirect.<!--{{cite journal \|last1=Ahmad \|first1=Nazir \|last2=Younus \|first2=Hossein A. \|last3=Chughtai \|first3=Adeel H. \|last4=Verport \|first4=Francis \|title=Metal-organic molecular cages: applications of biochemical implications \|journal=Chemical Society Reviews \|date=2015 \|volume=44 \|issue=1 \|pages=9–25 \|doi=10.1039/C4CS00222A \|pmid=25319756 }}-->
			*Note that [[Biomolecular complex]] had earlier been merged into [[Macromolecular assembly]].

	===Merge to Host-guest chemistry?===		===Merge to Host-guest chemistry?===
	<!--March "When the reaction of two compounds results in a product that contains all the mass of the two compounds, the product is called an addition compound. There are several kinds. In the rest of this chapter, we will discuss addition compounds in which the molecules of the starting materials remain more or less intact and weak bonds hold two or more molecules together. We can divide them into four broad classes: electron donor–acceptor complexes, complexes formed by crown ethers and similar compounds, inclusion compounds [urea, carcerands, cyclodextrins), and catenanes." March mentions host-guest only once.-->		<!--March "When the reaction of two compounds results in a product that contains all the mass of the two compounds, the product is called an addition compound. There are several kinds. In the rest of this chapter, we will discuss addition compounds in which the molecules of the starting materials remain more or less intact and weak bonds hold two or more molecules together. We can divide them into four broad classes: electron donor–acceptor complexes, complexes formed by crown ethers and similar compounds, inclusion compounds [urea, carcerands, cyclodextrins), and catenanes." March mentions host-guest only once.-->

Smokefoot: /* Merge and organization proposals */ refining plans

2024-11-03T16:05:48Z

Merge and organization proposals: refining plans

← Previous revision		Revision as of 16:05, 3 November 2024
Line 84:		Line 84:
	*[[Molecular recognition]] (32, several >2020). How does this topic differ from Supramolecular chemistry? Undefined by IUPAC.		*[[Molecular recognition]] (32, several >2020). How does this topic differ from Supramolecular chemistry? Undefined by IUPAC.
	*[[Intermolecular force]] seems almost too broad. Redundant with many articles.		*[[Intermolecular force]] seems almost too broad. Redundant with many articles.
	===Merge into ~~self~~-~~assembled~~ ...===		===Merge into [[Self-assembly]] ...===
	'''Parents''':		'''Parents''':
⚫	*[[Self-assembled monolayer]] 45 refs, most recent 2012. We cannot merge this one but its interesting to see how this area has ceased to gain editing.
	*[[Self-assembly]]. 50 refs. Some >2020. No IUPAC.		*[[Self-assembly]]. 50 refs. Some >2020. No IUPAC.
	*[[Molecular self-assembly]] (23 refs, most recent = 2014). Focuses on surfaces, so maybe merge into [[Self-assembled monolayer]]. Undefined by IUPAC.		*[[Molecular self-assembly]] (23 refs, most recent = 2014). Focuses on surfaces, so maybe merge into [[Self-assembled monolayer]]. Undefined by IUPAC.
Line 101:		Line 100:
	===Merge into supramolecular polymer===		===Merge into supramolecular polymer===
	Parent: [[Supramolecular polymer]]. 50 refs, several >2020. Most of the article written by User:Injp20 in one edit. Their only contribution to Wikipedia.		Parent: [[Supramolecular polymer]]. 50 refs, several >2020. Most of the article written by User:Injp20 in one edit. Their only contribution to Wikipedia.

⚫	*[[Macromolecular assembly]]. 18 refs, mostly 2016ish. Undefined by IUPAC. ~~Merge into [[Supramolecular polymer]].~~
			===Merge into [[Macromolecular assembly]]===
⚫	*[[Two-dimensional polymer]]. 50 refs. Undefined by IUPAC. ~~Merge into [[Supramolecular polymer]]. Imperfect fit.~~
		⚫	*parent: [[Macromolecular assembly]]. 18 refs, mostly 2016ish. Undefined by IUPAC.
		⚫	*[[Macromolecular cages]]. 11 refs. Pure homework assignment. Merge or redirect.<!--{{cite journal \|last1=Ahmad \|first1=Nazir \|last2=Younus \|first2=Hossein A. \|last3=Chughtai \|first3=Adeel H. \|last4=Verport \|first4=Francis \|title=Metal-organic molecular cages: applications of biochemical implications \|journal=Chemical Society Reviews \|date=2015 \|volume=44 \|issue=1 \|pages=9–25 \|doi=10.1039/C4CS00222A \|pmid=25319756 }}-->
	===Merge to Host-guest chemistry?===		===Merge to Host-guest chemistry?===
	<!--March "When the reaction of two compounds results in a product that contains all the mass of the two compounds, the product is called an addition compound. There are several kinds. In the rest of this chapter, we will discuss addition compounds in which the molecules of the starting materials remain more or less intact and weak bonds hold two or more molecules together. We can divide them into four broad classes: electron donor–acceptor complexes, complexes formed by crown ethers and similar compounds, inclusion compounds [urea, carcerands, cyclodextrins), and catenanes." March mentions host-guest only once.-->		<!--March "When the reaction of two compounds results in a product that contains all the mass of the two compounds, the product is called an addition compound. There are several kinds. In the rest of this chapter, we will discuss addition compounds in which the molecules of the starting materials remain more or less intact and weak bonds hold two or more molecules together. We can divide them into four broad classes: electron donor–acceptor complexes, complexes formed by crown ethers and similar compounds, inclusion compounds [urea, carcerands, cyclodextrins), and catenanes." March mentions host-guest only once.-->
Line 119:		Line 120:
	***[[cryptand]] 14 refs, most recent = 2001. Mature. Includes concept of "preorganization".		***[[cryptand]] 14 refs, most recent = 2001. Mature. Includes concept of "preorganization".
	***[[crown ether]]s. 18 refs, mostly pre 2000 it appears. Mature		***[[crown ether]]s. 18 refs, mostly pre 2000 it appears. Mature
⚫	**[[Macromolecular cages]]. 11 refs. Pure homework assignment. Merge or redirect.<!--{{cite journal \|last1=Ahmad \|first1=Nazir \|last2=Younus \|first2=Hossein A. \|last3=Chughtai \|first3=Adeel H. \|last4=Verport \|first4=Francis \|title=Metal-organic molecular cages: applications of biochemical implications \|journal=Chemical Society Reviews \|date=2015 \|volume=44 \|issue=1 \|pages=9–25 \|doi=10.1039/C4CS00222A \|pmid=25319756 }}-->
	*[[addition compound]], which redirects to [[Adduct]], should be redirected to [[inclusion compound]]		*[[addition compound]], which redirects to [[Adduct]], should be redirected to [[inclusion compound]]

	===Leave intact===		===Leave intact===
		⚫	*[[Self-assembled monolayer]] 45 refs, most recent 2012. We cannot merge this one but its interesting to see how this area has ceased to gain editing.
		⚫	*[[Two-dimensional polymer]]. 50 refs. Undefined by IUPAC.
	*[[Supramolecular catalysis]]. 30 refs, most recent = 2013. A selective focus on a few results. Almost all enzyme-catalyzed reactions involve supramolecular aspects.		*[[Supramolecular catalysis]]. 30 refs, most recent = 2013. A selective focus on a few results. Almost all enzyme-catalyzed reactions involve supramolecular aspects.
	*[[Clathrate hydrate]].		*[[Clathrate hydrate]].

Smokefoot: /* Leave intact */ **Coordination cage leave intact

2024-11-03T15:59:54Z

Leave intact: **Coordination cage leave intact

← Previous revision		Revision as of 15:59, 3 November 2024
Line 125:		Line 125:
	*[[Supramolecular catalysis]]. 30 refs, most recent = 2013. A selective focus on a few results. Almost all enzyme-catalyzed reactions involve supramolecular aspects.		*[[Supramolecular catalysis]]. 30 refs, most recent = 2013. A selective focus on a few results. Almost all enzyme-catalyzed reactions involve supramolecular aspects.
	*[[Clathrate hydrate]].		*[[Clathrate hydrate]].
			*[[Coordination cage]]. 15 refs, some 2015. Seems to be a mature, well-defined topic.
	====Peripheral====		====Peripheral====
	*[[Self-organization]], a very broad topic including cosmology, physics...		*[[Self-organization]], a very broad topic including cosmology, physics...

Smokefoot: /* Merge into self-assembled monolayer */ more planning

2024-11-03T15:59:11Z

Merge into self-assembled monolayer: more planning

← Previous revision		Revision as of 15:59, 3 November 2024
Line 84:		Line 84:
	*[[Molecular recognition]] (32, several >2020). How does this topic differ from Supramolecular chemistry? Undefined by IUPAC.		*[[Molecular recognition]] (32, several >2020). How does this topic differ from Supramolecular chemistry? Undefined by IUPAC.
	*[[Intermolecular force]] seems almost too broad. Redundant with many articles.		*[[Intermolecular force]] seems almost too broad. Redundant with many articles.
	===Merge into self-assembled ~~monolayer~~===		===Merge into self-assembled ...===
			'''Parents''':
	~~'''Parent''':~~ [[Self-assembled monolayer]] 45 refs, most recent 2012. We cannot merge this one but its interesting to see how this area has ceased to gain editing.		*[[Self-assembled monolayer]] 45 refs, most recent 2012. We cannot merge this one but its interesting to see how this area has ceased to gain editing.
	**[[Coordination cage]]. 15 refs, some 2015. Fujita, Raymond. Seems to be a mature topic.
⚫	*[[Molecular self-assembly]] (23 refs, most recent = 2014). Focuses on surfaces, so maybe merge into [[Self-assembled monolayer]]. Undefined by IUPAC.
	*[[Self-assembly]]. 50 refs. Some >2020. No IUPAC.		*[[Self-assembly]]. 50 refs. Some >2020. No IUPAC.
		⚫	*[[Molecular self-assembly]] (23 refs, most recent = 2014). Focuses on surfaces, so maybe merge into [[Self-assembled monolayer]]. Undefined by IUPAC.

	===Components of supramolecular ''bonding''===		===Components of supramolecular ''bonding''===
	each to be mentioned in Supramolecular chemistry as well as H-bonding and coordination complexes		each to be mentioned in Supramolecular chemistry as well as H-bonding and coordination complexes

Christian75: {{merged|Supermolecule}}

2024-11-03T15:58:15Z

← Previous revision		Revision as of 15:58, 3 November 2024
Line 3:		Line 3:
	}}		}}
	{{merged\|Supramolecular assembly}}		{{merged\|Supramolecular assembly}}
			{{merged\|Supermolecule}}

	==Why supramolecular chemistry, not supramolecular science?==		==Why supramolecular chemistry, not supramolecular science?==

Christian75: {{merged|Supramolecular assembly}}

2024-11-03T15:55:03Z

← Previous revision		Revision as of 15:55, 3 November 2024
Line 2:		Line 2:
	{{WikiProject Chemistry\|importance=Mid}}		{{WikiProject Chemistry\|importance=Mid}}
	}}		}}
			{{merged\|Supramolecular assembly}}

	==Why supramolecular chemistry, not supramolecular science?==		==Why supramolecular chemistry, not supramolecular science?==

Smokefoot: /* Merge proposals */ Clathrate hydrate

2024-10-28T19:17:56Z

Merge proposals: Clathrate hydrate

← Previous revision		Revision as of 19:17, 28 October 2024
Line 72:		Line 72:
	== Needs Examples ==		== Needs Examples ==
	Many topics in the first half of the article do not mention any specific chemicals, reactions, or examples. It is hard to understand what the author really means. I am a person who thinks from concrete examples. Could someone just mention an example in each paragraph that does not have one? [[User:GoodExplainer\|GoodExplainer]] ([[User talk:GoodExplainer\|talk]]) 06:02, 6 October 2020 (UTC)		Many topics in the first half of the article do not mention any specific chemicals, reactions, or examples. It is hard to understand what the author really means. I am a person who thinks from concrete examples. Could someone just mention an example in each paragraph that does not have one? [[User:GoodExplainer\|GoodExplainer]] ([[User talk:GoodExplainer\|talk]]) 06:02, 6 October 2020 (UTC)
	==Merge proposals==		==Merge and organization proposals==
	Two things are going on with this section: (i) an attempt to identify all articles that emphasize [[supramolecular chemistry]] and (ii) preparing to merge several.		Two things are going on with this section: (i) an attempt to identify all articles that emphasize [[supramolecular chemistry]] and (ii) preparing to merge several.

	Supramolecular chemistry is a large area as reflected in ~~many~~ books. The area is also somewhat vaguely defined.		Supramolecular chemistry is a large area as reflected in at least two books with that title, a journal, and a book series. The area is also somewhat vaguely defined.
	<!--IUPAC on Supramolecular chemistry "A field of chemistry related to species of greater complexity than molecules, that are held together and organized by means of intermolecular interactions. The objects of supramolecular chemistry are supermolecules and other polymolecular entities that result from the spontaneous association of a large number of components into a specific phase (membranes, vesicles, micelles, solid state structures etc.)"-->		<!--IUPAC on Supramolecular chemistry "A field of chemistry related to species of greater complexity than molecules, that are held together and organized by means of intermolecular interactions. The objects of supramolecular chemistry are supermolecules and other polymolecular entities that result from the spontaneous association of a large number of components into a specific phase (membranes, vesicles, micelles, solid state structures etc.)"-->
	===Merge into supramolecular chemistry===		===Merge into supramolecular chemistry===
Line 120:		Line 120:
	===Leave intact===		===Leave intact===
	*[[Supramolecular catalysis]]. 30 refs, most recent = 2013. A selective focus on a few results. Almost all enzyme-catalyzed reactions involve supramolecular aspects.		*[[Supramolecular catalysis]]. 30 refs, most recent = 2013. A selective focus on a few results. Almost all enzyme-catalyzed reactions involve supramolecular aspects.
			*[[Clathrate hydrate]].
	====Peripheral====		====Peripheral====
	*[[Self-organization]], a very broad topic including cosmology, physics...		*[[Self-organization]], a very broad topic including cosmology, physics...