Speleotherapy
| Speleotherapy | |
|---|---|
 Speleotherapy in Bad Soden-Salmünster, Germany. | |
| MeSH | D055161 |
Speleotherapy (Greek σπήλαιον spḗlaion "cave") is an alternative medicine respiratory therapy involving breathing inside a cave.
History
Hippocrates is claimed to believe that salt-based therapies, including inhaling steam from saltwater, provided relief of respiratory symptoms.[1] There are claims of improvements in the breathing of miners in Roman times and medieval times.[2] Speleotherapy hospitals existed in Italy in the 19th century. In the middle of the 19th century, a clinic, founded in Mammoth Cave (Kentucky, USA), was intended for tuberculosis patients. However, a few months after the death of five of the patients, the hospital was closed.[3][4]
The history of modern speleotherapy dates back to the 1950s. At this time, speleotherapeutic hospitals arose in several Eastern and Central European countries.
Residents of Ennepetal in Germany used the Kluterthöhle cave as a bomb shelter during WW2. Karl Hermann Spannagel began researching the therapeutic effect of caves.[5] Speleotherapeutic facilities in karst caves were started in Hungary and Czechoslovakia.
In 1968, in Solotvyn (now in Ukraine), the first speleotherapy clinic was opened on the territory of the USSR. In 1982, a climate chamber was patented, equipped with a salt filter-saturator to recreate the conditions of salt mines on the earth's surface.
Indications
The treatment is claimed to be used for bronchial asthma, bronchitis, allergic and chronic runny nose, allergic and chronic sinus diseases, various allergies and skin diseases, fibrosing alveolitis and croup. However, as of 2022, there is no evidence to support these claims.
Speleotherapy in the Czech Republic
The first speleotherapy in the Czechoslovakia was carried out by Mgr. Štefan Roda in Slovakia in the Tombašek Cave in the High Tatras (1969). In 1973–1976, doctors Timová and Valtrová from the Children's Clinic in Banská Bystrica treated childhood asthmatics with speleotherapy with favourable results, which were published in the medical literature.[6] [7] From 1981 to 1985, speleotherapy became the subject of official scientific research tasks, carried out under the responsibility of the Ministry of Health and the Geographical Institute of the Czechoslovak Academy of Sciences. In 1985, speleotherapy was recognized as an official climatic treatment method.[8]
According to the chairman of the International Union of Speleology's Standing Commission on Speleotherapy, Prof. Svetozar Dluholucky, M.D.,[9] speleotherapy is "a natural way of treating asthma and allergies, which it would be a sin not to use."[10] He has conducted research in Bystrianska Cave since 1974, according to which there has been a fivefold decrease in respiratory diseases and asthma in the children studied. In 1997, he conducted further research on 111 asthmatic children with the same results.[11] Allergists and immunologists remain sceptical, however.[10]
There are two speleotherapy centres in the Czech Republic: the Children's Treatment Centre in Ostrov u Macochy and the Children's Treatment Centre for Respiratory Diseases in Zlaté Hory. The children's sanatorium in Mladč-Vojtěchov was closed in 2014.[12]
Research
Hoyrmír Malota led a research team that tested patients of the speleotherapeutic sanatorium in Mladeč in 1985-1987 and came to the clinically verified knowledge "that individual factors of the underground environment, or their complex connected by internal and external interactions, stimulate and modulate the immune system of the human organism directly. He confirmed that repeated exposure to the underground environment - without the use of anti-asthmatic, antihistamine, or immunomodulatory pharmaceutical preparations - induces positive and measurable changes in secretory and lymphatic lysosomes and immunoglobins after only a few days of exposure to the degree that any existing artificial immunomodulators cannot achieve."[8][6]
Some factors characterizing cave endoclimates are controversial. While cave aerosols may theoretically contain high Ca and Mg ions, in practice, they are not present in the treatment sites known to date; Ca and Mg concentrations are everywhere the same as in the ambient air. It has been shown that the concentrations of Ca and Mg in cave air are not so significantly elevated as to be considered a therapeutic factor.[6] The elevated CO2 concentration, or the absence of allergens in the cave (the presence of some molds in very small amounts), or the absence of ozone is also questionable.[6]
According to the Cochrane Collaboration, three studies involving 124 children with asthma met the inclusion criteria for the 2001 meta-study. Still, only one study was of adequate methodological quality. Two studies reported that speleotherapy had a beneficial short-term effect on lung function. The other results could not be reliably evaluated. Due to the small number of studies, no reliable conclusion can be drawn from the available evidence on whether speleotherapy interventions are effective in treating chronic asthma. Randomized controlled trials with long-term follow-up are needed. No evidence of the effectiveness of speleotherapy was found from randomized controlled trials and further research is needed.[13]
According to a 2017 Romanian systematic review, speleotherapy is a valuable treatment method for asthma and other respiratory problems. Still, only a few studies can be found in international databases, reflecting the specificity of this field. On the other hand, basic studies in laboratory animals and in vitro cell cultures have demonstrated the efficacy and usefulness of speleotherapy.[14]
Quote
There are not so many karst caves, so salt mines have been used for treatment for a long time. So sanatoriums were created there, and it's called halotherapy. Wieliczka in Poland is very well known. Later on, there was an attempt to make halocaves artificially and they built a kind of igloo out of the salt that was mined. In various studies in the mid-1980s they compared the effect underground and in these salt chambers placed outside. It turned out that the above-ground salt caves had virtually no effect. And even, very easily contaminated with microbes, it can be dangerous. Many of the bacteria that cause severe respiratory infections love salt and settle in the surface layers of salt walls. Even salt mines that operate underground have very strict criteria to ensure that people do not contaminate the salt chamber with germs. Even in some, every three to four months, they grind off a few millimeters of the wall because of the bacilli. When their use was abandoned, it was quiet for about five years, and it started again. If it's not kept clean, it can be detrimental to health; some types of pneumococcus also stick in there. In our case, they tried to mitigate this by putting in air conditioning systems. But an artificial salt cave system that is fully air-conditioned cannot work. That's about like trying to replicate the Tatra air in a seventh-floor apartment block, it's stupid.
— Prof. MUDr. Svetozár DLUHOLUCKÝ, CSc[7]
References
- ^ History of Salt Therapy Illawarra Salt Therapy
- ^ "DSI". www.inhalodsi.eu. Retrieved 29 December 2021.
- ^ Magazine, Smithsonian. "When Tuberculosis Patients Quarantined Inside Kentucky's Mammoth Cave". Smithsonian Magazine. Retrieved 29 December 2021.
- ^ Bowen, Ashley (7 June 2016). "The Nation's First Tuberculosis Hospital Was Built Inside a Cave". Atlas Obscura. Retrieved 29 December 2021.
- ^ Cáp, Josef; Slavik, Pavel; Pecen, Ladislav (2007), Stanovení endogenního kortizolu u dìtí (PDF) (in Czech), archived from the original (PDF) on 18 July 2011
- ^ a b c d Grossová, Jana (2009). "Efektivita speleoterapie u dětí s chronickým onemocněním z pohledu rodičů a pedagogů" (PDF). Univerzita Tomáše Bati ve Zlíně, Fakulta humanitních studií.
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - ^ a b Skořepa, Hynek (21 December 2021). "Zajímavosti z historie a současnosti speleoterapie".
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - ^ a b Jirkaůl, Zdeněk (2001). Speleoterapie: principy a zkušenosti. Olomouc: Univerzita Palackého. p. 282. ISBN 80-244-0346-3.
- ^ Bartošovičová, Marta (13 November 2019). "Profesor Svetozár Dluholucký získal ocenenie Osobnosť vedy a techniky 2019". Veda Na Dosah. Centrum vedecko-technických informácií Slovenskej republiky.
- ^ a b Okoličániová, Eva (26 August 2011). "Speleoterapia nenahrádza liečbu, ale jej efekt je nepopierateľný". Our Media SR.
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - ^ Voštenáková, Zuzana (5 April 2011). "Speleoterapia". Bedeker zdravia.
{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=(help) - ^ Tauberová, Daniela (29 April 2019). "Bývalá ozdravovna ve Vojtěchově našla majitele. Její další osud je ve hvězdách". Deník.cz. Vltava Labe Media.
- ^ Beamon, Sylvia P; Falkenbach, Albrecht; Fainburg, Grigory; Linde, Klaus (23 April 2001). "Speleotherapy for asthma". Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Cochrane Collaboration. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD001741. ISSN 1469-493X.
- ^ Munteanu, Constantin (1 December 2017). "Speleotherapy - scientific relevance in the last five years (2013 – 2017) – A systematic review". Balneo Research Journal. 8 (4). Romanian Association of Balneology, Editura Balneara: 252–254. doi:10.12680/balneo.2017.161. ISSN 2069-7619.
External links
- Dunning, Brian (20 August 2013). "Skeptoid #376: Salt Therapies". Skeptoid.