Canaanite shift

In historical linguistics, the Canaanite shift is a sound change that took place in the Canaanite dialects, which belong to the Northwest Semitic branch of the Semitic languages family. This sound change caused Proto-NW-Semitic *ā (long a) to turn into ō (long o) in Proto-Canaanite. It accounts, for example, for the difference between the second vowel ofHebrew שלום (šalom, earlier šalōm) and its Arabic cognate سلام (salām). The original word was probably *šalāmu, with the ā preserved in Arabic, but transformed into ō in Hebrew.

Nature and Cause

This vowel shift is well attested in Hebrew and other Canaanite languages, but its exact nature is unclear and contested.

Theory of Unconditioned Shift

Many scholars consider this shift to be unconditioned. This position states that there were no conditioning factors such as stress or surrounding consonants which affected whether or not any given Proto-Semitic *ā became ō in Canaanite. Such scholars point to the fact that Proto-Semitic *ā virtually always reflects as ō in Hebrew.

Theory of Stress Consitioning

Some other scholars point to Hebrew words like שמאלי, in which the original *ā is thought to be preserved. Since such a preservation would be hard to explain by secondary processes like borrowing or analogy, they often assume that the shift was conditional and took place only in stressed syllables and that later, many words changed their form in analogy to other words in the same paradigm. As a result, the conditional nature of the shift became indistinct. 

Responses to Stress Conditioning Theory

Those who support a theory of unconditioned shift contend that this theory does not account for the fact that often *ā became ō even in positions where it was neither stressed nor part of an inflectional or derivational paradigm, and that such forms as שמאלי may indeed be a secondary development, since שמאל, the unsuffixed underlying form of the word, actually does contain an o. The a of שמאלי, therefore could be explained as having occurred after the vowel shift had ceased to be synchronically productive.

A parallel may be found in the pre-classical history of Latin, where a phenomenon called rhotacism affected all instances of intervocalic /s/ turning them into /r/. Thus rus (countryside,) for example, took the oblique form ruri from *rusi. The phenomenon, naturally, failed to affect instances of intervocalic /s/ formed after it had become productive. Thus essus was not rhotacized because, as a leveling of *ed- and -tus it did not, at the time of the rhotic phenomenon, have an /s/ to be transformed.

In much the same way the shape of such words as שמאלי may, in fact, represent a secondary process occurring after the Canaanite shift ceased to be productive.

Hebrew-Arabic parallels

The shift was so productive in Canaanite languages that it altered their inflectional and derivational morphologies wherever they contained the reflex of a pre-Canaanite *ā, as can be seen in Hebrew, the most attested of Canaanite languages, by comparing it with Arabic, a well-attested non-Canaanite language.

Present participle of Qal verbs:

Arabic fā‘il vs. Hebrew pō‘el

Arabic	Translation	Hebrew	Translation
كاتب kātib	Writer	כותב kōtev	One who is writing
راقص rāqiṣ	Dancer	רוקד rōqed	Dancer, dancing (attrib.)
كاهن kāhin	Soothsayer, augur, priest	כּהן kōhen	Priest, male descendant of Aaron

Feminine Plural

Arabic -āt vs. Hebrew -ōt

Arabic	Translation	Hebrew	Translation
بنات bināt	Daughters	בנות banōt	Daughters
مئات mi'āt	Hundreds	מאות me'ōt	Hundreds
اتنات atanāt	She-donkeys	אתנות atonōt	Donkeys
مجلات majallāt	Periodicals	מגילות megillōt	Scrolls

Other Words

Arabic	Hebrew	Translation
لسان lisān	לשון lašōn	Tongue, Language
لا lā	לא lo	No
رأس ra's	ראש roš	Head
ذراع ðirā‘	זרוע zərō‘	Arm
عالم ‘ālam	עולם ‘ōlam	World, Universe

In two of the above lexical items (lo and roš) one will notice that the shift did not only affect long vowels, but also short vowels occurring in the vicinity of a historically attested glottal stop in Canaanite.

Uses of the Shift

Often when new source material in an old Semitic language is uncovered, the Canaanite shift may be used to date the source material or to establish that the source material is written in a specifically Canaanite language. The shift is especially useful since it affects long vowels whose presence is likely to be recorded by matres lectionis such as aleph and waw, even in a defective consonantal script. In languages where the shift occurs, it also gives historical linguists reason to suppose that other shifts may have taken place.

References

• Blau, Joshua (1996), Studies in Hebrew Linguistics, Jerusalem: The Magnes Press, The Hebrew University
• Cross, Frank (1980), Newly Found Inscriptions in Old Canaanite and Early Phoenician Scripts, The American Schools of Oriental Research
• Wehr, Hans (1993), Arabic-English Dictionary
• Fox, Joshua (1996), A Sequence of Vowel Shifts in Phoenician and Other Languages