Jump to content

Talk:Elbląg

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This is an old revision of this page, as edited by 217.98.151.xxx (talk) at 18:12, 12 October 2001 (According to most popular theories, Baltic languages are not Slavic language. But of course it has nothing to do with Germanic languages.). The present address (URL) is a permanent link to this revision, which may differ significantly from the current revision.

(diff) ← Previous revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)

In 1945 Elbing was taken over by Poland, the native inhabitants were expelled and replaced by Poles. The city was renamed Elblag. After the fall of the Iron Curtain there is a small minority of original Elbinger inhabitants in Elbing/Elblag? today, who are now allowed to speak their native language and use their none-Polish names once again.


What a mess. I have made the following stab at clarifying and NPOVing this paragraph:


1. The "Elbing/Elblag" construction has been resolved to just "Elblag". The sentence containing it refers to post-1945, when the city was no longer named Elbing -- referring to it as so is disingenuous.


2. There's a logical contradiction in the final clause. If the "original Elbinger"s (more on that in a second) were expelled from Poland, the Polish government were obviously not in a position to keep them from speaking German. One or the other could have happened -- I assumed it was the expulsion.


3. "Original Elbinger" is also disingenuous. The city was founded in the 13th century, hence I would imagine all the "original" inhabitants died sometime before 1300 AD. Replaced with "the city's German-speaking inhabitants."


-- Paul Drye

yep, all those are reasonable decisions. --MichaelTinkler


I am somewhat uncomfortable (ok, very uncomfortable) with the whole "original" thing. It would be good to know:
  1. Was the expulsion forcible? or did the 4 powers say to the German-speakers that they would henceforth be living in poland, so they could leave if they didn't like it?


  1. How many of these German speakers had been sent in as colonists by the Nazi regime?


we are by no means hearing the complete story here



For church records filmed by the LDS Latter Day Saints , Utah

for Elbing, Westprussia, Prussia, Germany

http://www.familysearch.com


Topic

Germany, Preußen, Westpreußen, Elbing - Church records



Titles

Kirchenbuch, 1625-1946 / Evangelische Kirche Sankt Annen Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1622-1827 / Evangelische Kirche Heiliger Leichnam Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1626-1831 / Evangelische Kirche Sankt Paulus Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1577-1816 / Evangelische Kirche Heilige Drei Könige Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1604-1877 / Evangelische Kirche. Sankt Marien Hauptkirche Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1642-1881 / Katholische Kirche Sankt Nikolai Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1744-1942 / Mennoniten Gemeinde Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1746-1809 / Preußen. Armee. Infanterie Regiment 04

Kirchenbuch, 1746-1868 / Preußen. Armee. Infanterie Regiment 14

Kirchenbuch, 1746-1920 / Evangelische Kirche. Militärgemeinde Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1871-1945 / Katholisch-Apostolische Gemeinde Elbing

Kirchenbuch, 1840-1925 / Baptisten Gemeinde Elbing

Record of members, 1900-1923 / Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Königsberg Branch (Ostpreußen)

Record of members, 1901-1913 / Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Stolp Branch (Pommern)

Record of members, 1901-1930 / Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Elbing Branch (Westpreußen)


© 2000 Intellectual Reserve, Inc. All rights reserved.


Just to look at  , keep the url, you can check on any city



Original Elbinger are some citizens of Elbing, remaining in Eilbing after it was changed to Elblag by Poland . After the Iron Curtain fell, the Germans in Poland have minority right now,

They have been able to restore their German names, The Elbinger German minority have a Elbing

newspaper .



Besides, Poland had to sign a treaty, allowing German language to the Autochtones again. Maps in Europe are in both languages Danzig/Gdanzk Elbing /Elblag etc. H.Jonat





Can I point out that there is no evidence for such a place as Old Prussi Land, in the sense of anythig besides "here lie dragons" on any map? It's just part of some nationalist ideal to give Prussia some proto-national roots, and fits in with Prussian saga literature, which seems to be at least derived, if not downright stolen, from information we have about the Saxons and Friesians before their conversion. If you look at "Old Prussian" the language, it's a Baltic, i.e., SLAVIC language. So even if all of this Old Prussi stuff fits in, it certainly doesn't mesh with a Germanic heritage...J Hofmann Kemp


According to most popular theories, Baltic languages are not Slavic language.

But of course it has nothing to do with Germanic languages. --Taw