Lyndon B. Johnson judicial appointment controversies

During President Lyndon B. Johnson's presidency, federal judicial appointments played a central role. Johnson appointed two individuals to the Supreme Court of the United States in just over five years as president.

In 1965, Johnson nominated his friend Abe Fortas to the Supreme Court, and he was confirmed by the United States Senate. In 1967, Johnson nominated Thurgood Marshall to the Supreme Court, and he also was confirmed by the Senate. In 1968, however, Johnson made two failed nominations to the Supreme Court. He nominated Fortas to become Chief Justice of the Supreme Court to replace the retiring Earl Warren, and he nominated Homer Thornberry to replace Fortas as Associate Justice. However, Johnson wound up withdrawing Fortas' nomination after his confirmation hearing went badly, and he was not able to make another Chief Justice nomination before his presidency ended. As a result, he also ended up withdrawing Thornberry's nomination. Ultimately, Johnson's successor, President Richard Nixon, appointed Warren E. Burger as Chief Justice of the United States. Nixon also appointed Harry Blackmun to fill Fortas' seat after his previous nominations of Clement Haynsworth and G. Harrold Carswell to that seat both were rejected by the United States Senate.

At the appellate level, Johnson formally nominated one person, Barefoot Sanders, for a federal appellate judgeship who was never confirmed. The United States Senate did not act on Sanders' nomination before his presidency ended, and Nixon did not renominate him. Johnson also considered other appeals court nominees whom he never wound up nominating.

List of failed appellate nominees

• United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit
  • Seat - Barefoot Sanders (judgeship later filled by Nixon nominee George MacKinnon) (Sanders later was appointed by President Jimmy Carter to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas)

In addition to Sanders, three Johnson nominees to district judgeships were not voted on by the United States Senate before Johnson's presidency ended: David Bress; Cecil F. Poole to the United States District Court for the Northern District of California; and William Byrne, to the United States District Court for the Central District of California. Johnson renominated Sanders, Poole, Bress and Byrne right before his presidency. However, three days after taking office, Nixon withdrew all four nominations, although he later wound up renominating Byrne to the same court in 1971, and Byrne quickly won Senate confirmation. Poole was renominated by President Gerald Ford to a seat on the same court in 1976, and was quickly confirmed by the Senate.

In Nixon's first news conference after his inauguration, he explained his decision to withdraw those four nominations as follows:

Ramsey Clark discussed this matter during the period and the inauguration with Attorney General Mitchell. He asked Attorney General Mitchell to ask me whether I would object to action on the part of President Johnson in the event that he did submit these appointments to the Senate. My reply was that I would not object to President Johnson's submitting such - submitting names to the Senate...As you ladies and gentlemen are quite aware, I have scrupulously followed the line we have one President at a time and that he must continue to be President until he leaves office on January the 20th. However, I did not have any understanding with the President directly and no one including Attorney General Mitchell as far as I was concerned had any discretion to agree to a deal that those nominations having been made would be approved by me. I have withdrawn them and now I'm going to examine each one of them, and as I've already indicated I have decided that in at least some instances some of the names will be resubmitted.

— Richard Nixon

Others who were considered for nomination

In 1964, Johnson considered nominating either noted civil rights lawyer Bernard Segal or William Thaddeus Coleman, Jr. to fill a vacancy on the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit that had been created by the death of Herbert Funk Goodrich. Johnson personally approached Coleman regarding the nomination, but Coleman declined the offer. Johnson ultimately wound up nominating Abraham Lincoln Freedman to the seat, and he was confirmed quickly by the United States Senate.

In 1968, Johnson had wanted to nominate liberal Republican Sen. Thomas Kuchel to a newly created seat on the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit after he lost re-election in his party's primary that year. However, because the judgeship was created while Kuchel was in the Senate, Kuchel was constitutionally barred from being appointed to that seat during the final months of his Senate term (and the final months of Johnson's presidency).

See also

• United States federal judge
• Federal judicial appointment history
• President Nixon's judicial appointments controversy
• President Ford's judicial appointments controversy
• President Carter's judicial appointments controversy
• President Reagan's judicial appointments controversy
• President George H.W. Bush's judicial appointments controversy
• President Clinton's judicial appointments controversy
• President George W. Bush's judicial appointments controversy