Tetrarchy

Template:Tetrarchy

The term "tetrarchy" (from the Template:Lang-el, tetrarchia, "leadership of four [people]")^[a] describes any form of government where power is divided among four individuals, but in modern usage usually refers to the system instituted by Roman Emperor Diocletian in 293, marking the end of the Crisis of the Third Century and the recovery of the Roman Empire. This tetrarchy lasted until c. 313, when mutually destructive conflict eliminated most of the claimants to power, leaving Constantine in control of the western half of the empire, and Licinius in control of the eastern half.

Terminology

Although the term "tetrarch" was current in antiquity, it was never used of the imperial college under Diocletian. Instead, the term was used to describe independent portions of a kingdom that were ruled under separate leaders. The tetrarchy of Judaea, established after the death of Herod the Great, is the most famous example of the antique tetrarchy. The term was understood in the Latin world as well, where Pliny the Elder glossed it as follows: "each is the equivalent of a kingdom, and also part of one" (regnorum instar singulae et in regna contribuuntur).^[1]

As used by the ancients, the term describes not only different governments, but also a different system of government from the Diocletianic arrangements. The Judaean tetrarchy was a set of four independent and distinct states, where each tetrarch ruled a quarter of a kingdom as they saw fit; the Diocletianic tetrarchy was a college led by a single supreme leader. When later authors described the period, this is what they emphasized: Ammianus had Constantius II admonish Julian for disobedience by appealing to the example in submission set by Diocletian's lesser colleagues; Julian himself compared the Diocletianic tetrarchs to a chorus surrounding a leader, speaking in unison under his command. Only Lactantius, a contemporary of Diocletian and a deep ideological opponent of the Diocletianic state, referred to the tetrarchs as a simple multiplicity of rulers.^[2]

Much modern scholarship was written without the term. Although Edward Gibbon pioneered the description of the Diocletianic government as a "New Empire", he never used the term "tetrarchy"; neither did Theodor Mommsen. It did not appear in the literature until used in 1887 by schoolmaster Hermann Schiller in a two-volume handbook on the Roman Empire (Geschichte der Römischen Kaiserzeit), to wit: "die diokletianische Tetrarchie". Even so, the term did not catch on in the literature until Otto Seeck used it in 1897.^[3]

Creation

The first phase, sometimes referred to as the diarchy ("rule of two"), involved the designation of the general Maximian as co-emperor—firstly as Caesar (junior emperor) in 285, followed by his promotion to Augustus in 286. Diocletian took care of matters in the eastern regions of the empire while Maximian similarly took charge of the western regions. In 293, Diocletian thought that more focus was needed on both civic and military problems, so with Maximian's consent, he expanded the imperial college by appointing two Caesars (one responsible to each Augustus)—Galerius and Constantius Chlorus.^[4]

In 305, the senior emperors jointly abdicated and retired, allowing Constantius and Galerius to be elevated in rank to Augustus. They in turn appointed two new Caesars — Severus II in the west under Constantius, and Maximinus in the east under Galerius — thereby creating the second Tetrarchy.

Regions and capitals

The four tetrarchs based themselves not at Rome but in other cities closer to the frontiers, mainly intended as headquarters for the defence of the empire against bordering rivals (notably Sassanian Persia) and barbarians (mainly Germanic, and an unending sequence of nomadic or displaced tribes from the eastern steppes) at the Rhine and Danube. These centres are known as the tetrarchic capitals. Although Rome ceased to be an operational capital, Rome continued to be nominal capital of the entire Roman Empire, not reduced to the status of a province but under its own, unique Prefect of the City (praefectus urbi, later copied in Constantinople).

The four tetrarchic capitals were:

Nicomedia in northwestern Asia Minor (modern Izmit in Turkey), a base for defence against invasion from the Balkans and Persia's Sassanids was the capital of Diocletian, the eastern (and most senior) Augustus; in the final reorganisation by Constantine the Great, in 318, the equivalent of his domain, facing the most redoubtable foreign enemy, Sassanid Persia, became the pretorian prefecture Oriens, 'the East', the core of later Byzantium.
Sirmium (modern Sremska Mitrovica in the Vojvodina region of modern Serbia, and near Belgrade, on the Danube border) was the capital of Galerius, the eastern Caesar; this was to become the Balkans-Danube prefecture Illyricum.
Mediolanum (modern Milan, near the Alps) was the capital of Maximian, the western Augustus; his domain became "Italia et Africa", with only a short exterior border.
Augusta Treverorum (modern Trier, in Germany) was the capital of Constantius Chlorus, the western Caesar, near the strategic Rhine border; it had been the capital of Gallic emperor Tetricus I. This quarter became the prefecture Galliae.

Aquileia, a port on the Adriatic coast, and Eboracum (modern York, in northern England near the Celtic tribes of modern Scotland and Ireland), were also significant centres for Maximian and Constantius respectively.

In terms of regional jurisdiction there was no precise division among the four tetrarchs, and this period did not see the Roman state actually split up into four distinct sub-empires. Each emperor had his zone of influence within the Roman Empire, but little more, mainly high command in a 'war theater'. Each tetrarch was himself often in the field, while delegating most of the administration to the hierarchic bureaucracy headed by his respective Pretorian Prefect, each supervising several Vicarii, the governors-general in charge of another, lasting new administrative level, the civil diocese. For a listing of the provinces, now known as eparchy, within each quarter (known as a praetorian prefecture), see Roman province.

In the West, the Augustus Maximian controlled the provinces west of the Adriatic Sea and the Syrtis, and within that region his Caesar, Constantius, controlled Gaul and Britain. In the East, the arrangements between the Augustus Diocletian and his Caesar, Galerius, were much more flexible.

However, it appears that some contemporary and later writers, such as the Christian author Lactantius, and Sextus Aurelius Victor (who wrote about fifty years later and from uncertain sources), misunderstood the tetrarchic system in this respect, believing it to have involved a stricter division of territories among the four emperors.

Public image

Although power was shared in the tetrarchic system, the public image of the four emperors in the imperial college was carefully managed to give the appearance of a united empire (patrimonium indivisum). This was especially important after the numerous civil wars of the 3rd century.

The tetrarchs appeared identical in all official portraits. Coinage dating from the tetrarchic period depicts every emperor with identical features—only the inscriptions on the coins indicate which one of the four emperors is being shown. The Byzantine sculpture Portrait of the Four Tetrarchs shows the tetrarchs again with identical features and wearing the same military costume.

Military successes

One of the greatest problems facing emperors in the Third Century Crisis was that they were only ever able to personally command troops on one front at any one time. While Aurelian and Probus were prepared to accompany their armies thousands of miles between war regions, this was not an ideal solution. Furthermore, it was risky for an emperor to delegate power in his absence to a subordinate general, who might win a victory and then be proclaimed as a rival emperor himself by his troops (which often happened). All members of the imperial college, on the other hand, were of essentially equal rank, despite two being senior emperors and two being junior; their functions and authorities were also equal.

Under the Tetrarchy a number of important military victories were secured. Both the Dyarchic and the tetrarchic system ensured that an emperor was nearby to every crisis area to personally direct and remain in control of campaigns simultaneously on more than just one front. After suffering a defeat by the Persians in 296, Galerius crushed Narseh in 298—reversing a series of Roman defeats throughout the century—capturing members of the imperial household and a substantial amount of booty and gaining a highly favourable peace treaty, which secured peace between the two powers for a generation. Similarly, Constantius defeated the British usurper Allectus, Maximian pacified the Gauls, and Diocletian crushed the revolt of Domitianus in Egypt.

Demise

When in 305 the 20-year term of Diocletian and Maximian ended, both abdicated. Their Caesares, Galerius and Constantius Chlorus, were both raised to the rank of Augustus, and two new Caesares were appointed: Maximinus (Caesar to Galerius) and Flavius Valerius Severus (Caesar to Constantius). These four formed the second tetrarchy.

However, the system broke down very quickly thereafter. When Constantius died in 306, Galerius promoted Severus to Augustus while Constantine, Constantius' son, was proclaimed Augustus by his father's troops. At the same time, Maxentius, the son of Maximian, who also resented being left out of the new arrangements, defeated Severus before forcing him to abdicate and then arranging his murder in 307. Maxentius and Maximian both then declared themselves Augusti. By 308 there were therefore no fewer than four claimants to the rank of Augustus (Galerius, Constantine, Maximian and Maxentius), and only one to that of Caesar (Maximinus).

In 308 Galerius, together with the retired emperor Diocletian and the supposedly retired Maximian, called an imperial "conference" at Carnuntum on the River Danube. The council agreed that Licinius would become Augustus in the West, with Constantine as his Caesar. In the East, Galerius remained Augustus and Maximinus remained his Caesar. Maximian was to retire, and Maxentius was declared an usurper. This agreement proved disastrous: by 308 Maxentius had become de facto ruler of Italy and Africa even without any imperial rank, and neither Constantine nor Maximinus—who had both been Caesares since 306 and 305 respectively—were prepared to tolerate the promotion of the Augustus Licinius as their superior.

After an abortive attempt to placate both Constantine and Maximinus with the meaningless title filius Augusti ("son of the Augustus", essentially an alternative title for Caesar), they both had to be recognised as Augusti in 309. However, four full Augusti all at odds with each other did not bode well for the tetrarchic system.

Between 309 and 313 most of the claimants to the imperial office died or were killed in various civil wars. Constantine forced Maximian's suicide in 310. Galerius died naturally in 311. Maxentius was defeated by Constantine at the Battle of the Milvian Bridge in 312 and subsequently killed. Maximinus committed suicide at Tarsus in 313 after being defeated in battle by Licinius.

By 313, therefore, there remained only two emperors: Constantine in the West and Licinius in the East. The tetrarchic system was at an end, although it took until 324 for Constantine to finally defeat Licinius, reunite the two halves of the Roman Empire and declare himself sole Augustus.

Timeline

Diarchy 21 July 285 - 1 March 293
Western Roman Empire	Eastern Roman Empire
Augustus Maximian (250-310)	Augustus Diocletian (244-311)
Usurpers (date)
Carausius (286-293) Roman Britain

First Tetrarchy 1 March 293 - 1 May 305
Dioceses of Spain, Italy y Africa	Dioceses of the East, Asia y Pontus
Augustus Maximian (250-310)	Augustus Diocletian (244-311)
Dioceses of Gaul, Vienne and Britain	Dioceses of Pannonia, Moesia and Thrace
Caesar Constantius Chlorus (250-306)	Caesar Galerius (250-311)
Usurpers (date)
Carausius (286-293) Roman Britain Allectus (293-296) Roman Britain]]	Domitius Domitianus (297) Roman Egypt Achilleus (297-298) Roman Egypt

Second Tetrarchy 1 May 305 - 25 July 306
Dioceses of Gaul, Vienne, Spain y Britain^[5]	Dioceses of Pannonia, Moesia, Thrace, Pontus y Asia^[5]
Augustus Constantius Chlorus (250-306)	Augustus Galerius (250-311)
Dioceses of Italy and Africa^[5]	Dioceses of the East^[5]
Caesar Valerius Severus (¿-307)	Caesar Maximinus Daia (270-313)

Third Tetrarchy 25 July 306 - 16 August 307
Dioceses of Italy, Africa, Hispania and Pannonia^[5]	Dioceses of Moesia, Macedonia, Thrace, Pontus and Asia^[5]
Augustus Valerius Severus (¿-307)	Augustus Galerius (250-311)
Dioceses of Britain, Vienne and Gaul^[5]	Diocesis of the East^[5]
Caesar Constantine I (272-337)	Caesar Maximinus Daia (270-313)
Usurpers (date)
Augustus Maxentius (306-312) firstly Rome, then Italy and Africa Augustus Maximian (306-309) Italy and Africa

Fourth Tetrarchy 16 August 307 - May 311
Dioceses of Gaul, Vienne, Hispania y Britain	Dioceses of Moesia, Macedonia, Thrace, Pontus and Asia
Augustus Constantine I (272-337)	Augustus Galerius (250-311)
Dioceses of Pannonia	Dioceses of the East
Augustus Licinius (250-325)	Augustus Maximinus Daia (270-313)
Dioceses of Italy and Africa
Augustus Maxentius (306-312) Augustus Maximian (306-309) He enfrend his son, he took refuge in Arles under protection of Constantine. His rebelled against this one and he was killed in 310
Usurpers(date)
Domitius Alexander (309-311) in Africa against Maxentius

Fifth Tetrarchy May 311 - August 313
Dioceses of Gaul, Vienne, Hispania, Britain (Italy and Africa)^[6]	Dioceses of Pannonia, Moesia, Macedonia y Thrace (Asia, Pontus and of the East)^[7]
Augustus Constantine I (272-337)	Augustus Licinius (250-325)
Dioceses de Italy and Africa	Dioceses de Asia, Pontus and of the East
Augustus Maxentius (306-312)	Augustus Maximinus Daia (270-313)

Last Tetrarchy August 313 - 18 september 324
Dioceses de Gaul, Vienne, Hispania, Britain, Italy and Africa (Pannonia, Moesia and Macedonia)^[8]	Dioceses de Pannonia, Moesia, Macedonia, Thrace, Asia, Pontus and of the East
Augustus Constantine I (272-337)	Augustus Licinius (250-325)
Western Roman Empire	Eastern Roman Empire
Caesar Crispus (305-326) he was proclamed by his father Constantine in 317 Caesar Constantine II (317-337) he was proclamed by his father Constantine in 317	Augustus Valerius Valens (¿-317) co-emperor with Licinius in Pannonia, elevated as Augustus by Licinius, but he had Valens executed Caesar Licinius II (316-326) he was raised to the rank of Caesar by his father Licinius in 317 Augustus Martinianus (¿-325) nominal co-emperor with Licinius in 324

286–293

Augusti: Oriens Diocletian (286–293); Occidens Maximian (286–293)

293–305

Augusti: Oriens Diocletian (286–305); Italia et Africa Maximian (286–305)
Caesars: Illyricum Galerius (293–305); Gallia et Hispaniae Constantius Chlorus (293–305)
Usurpers: Leaders of the Bagaudae in Gaul Amandus and Aelianus (285–286); Africa Zeugitana Sabinus Julianus (c. 285–293); Britannia Carausius (286–293); Britannia Allectus (293–296); Aegyptus Domitius Domitianus (296–297); Aegyptus Aurelius Achilleus (297–298); Syria Coele Eugenius (303/304)

305–306

Augusti: Illyricum Galerius (305–306); Gallia, Hispaniae et Britannia Constantius Chlorus (305–306)
Caesars: Oriens Maximinus Daia (305–306); Italia et Africa Flavius Valerius Severus (305–306)

306–307

Augusti: Illyricum Galerius (306–307); Italia et Africa Flavius Valerius Severus (306–307)
Caesars: Oriens Maximinus Daia (306–307); Gallia, Hispaniae et Britannia Constantine I (306–307); Roma Maxentius (307)

307–313

Augusti: Illyricum Galerius (307–311); Gallia, Hispaniae et Britannia Constantine I (307–…); Thracia et Pontus to Taurus Licinius (308–…); Italia Maxentius (307–312); Oriens from Taurus to Aegyptus Maximinus Daia (310–313); Italia Maximian (307–310)

Caesars: Oriens from Taurus to Aegyptus Maximinus Daia (307–310)

Usurpers: Africa Domitius Alexander (308–311)

313–324

Augusti: Oriens Licinius (313–324); Occidens Constantine I (313–324); Oriens Sextus Martinianus (324)

Caesars: Italia Bassianus (313–314); Illyricum Valerius Valens (314–316); Oriens Licinius the Younger (317–324); Occidens Crispus (317–326)

324

Augustus: Constantine I

Others

1. Tetrarchy until 1 May 305

	West	East
Augusti	Maximian	Diocletian
Caesares	Constantius Chlorus	Galerius

2. Tetrarchy until July 306

After the retirement of the two Augusti both previous Caesares succeeded them, and two new Caesares were appointed. Maximinus Daia was Galerius' nephew.

	West	East
Augusti	Constantius Chlorus	Galerius
Caesares	Severus	Maximinus Daia

3. Tetrarchy until 16 May 307

After the death of Constantius his legions proclaim his son Constantine the new Augustus, but Galerius elevates Severus to be the new junior Augustus and compensates Constantine with the rank of Caesar.

	West	East
Augusti	Severus	Galerius
Caesares	Constantine	Maximinus Daia

4. Tetrarchy from 18 November 308 to the beginning of May 311

After the death of Severus, Constantine does not succeed him. At the council of Carnutum, Diocletian decides that Licinius will be the new Augustus of the West.

	West	East
Augusti	Licinius	Galerius
Caesares	Constantine	Maximinus Daia

5. Tetrarchy from May 311

After the death of Galerius he was succeeded by Maximinus Daia in as Augustus of the East, but is crowded by Licinius, who wants to have the status of the senior Augustus. Maximinus appoints no new Caesar, although it was assumed that this position should later on be filled out with the son of Severus, Flavius Severianus, or at least that he was scheduled for this position.

	West	East
Augusti	Licinius	Maximinus Daia
Caesares	Constantine	vacant

(6.) Tetrarchy after 8 October 316 to the end of 316

Shortly before the turn of the year 316/317, Constantine, now Augustus in the West, appointed a Caesar, while Licinius briefly appointed one of his officers, Valerius Valens, as the third Augustus. This was apparent from coins, though Valens was apparently inferior to Licinius, who soon executed him. Even the chronology is unclear, as the date stamping could also be the turn of the year 314/315.

	West	East
Augusti	Constantine	Licinius and Valerius Valens
Caesares	Bassianus

(7.) Tetrarchy from 1 March 317 to 18 September 324

The tetrarchic system is at its end. Both Augusti appoint their own sons as co-emperors, restoring a dynastic system. However, before his death, Licinius appoints the General Martinianus on 3 July 324 as Augustus in name only, as Martinianus was intended to replace Constantine in the west.

	West	East
Augusti	Constantine I	Licinius
Caesares	Crispus and Constantine II	Licinius II

Legacy

Although the tetrarchic system as such only lasted until 313 CE, many aspects of it survived. The fourfold regional division of the empire continued in the form of Praetorian prefectures, each of which was overseen by a praetorian prefect and subdivided into administrative dioceses, and often reappeared in the title of the military supra-provincial command assigned to a magister militum.

The pre-existing notion of consortium imperii, the sharing of imperial power, and the notion that an associate to the throne was the designated successor (possibly conflicting with the notion of hereditary claim by birth or adoption), was to reappear repeatedly.

The idea of the two halves, the east and the west, re-emerged and eventually resulted in the permanent de facto division into two separate Roman empires after the death of Theodosius I, though it is important to remember that the empire was never formally divided, the emperors of the eastern and western halves legally ruling as one imperial college until the fall of Rome's western empire left Byzantium, the "second Rome", sole direct heir.

Other examples

Tetrarchies in the ancient world existed in both Thessaly (in northern Greece) and Galatia (in central Asia Minor; including Lycaonia) as well as among the British Cantiaci.
The constellation of Jewish principalities in the Herodian kingdom of Judea was known as a tetrarchy; see Tetrarchy (Judea).
In the novel The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, the Pevensie siblings rule Narnia as a tetrarchy of two kings and two queens.

Notes

^ Historian David Potter translates the term as "gang of four". See idem., Constantine the Emperor (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013), 1.

Citations

^ Qtd. and tr. Leadbetter, Galerius, 3.
^ Leadbetter, Galerius, 3.
^ Leadbetter, Galerius, 3–4.
^ The chronology has been thoroughly established by Kolb, Diocletian, and Kuhoff, Diokletian.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h Bajo, F. (1990) Constantino y sus sucesores. La conversión del Imperio. Akal Historia del mundo antiguo, pág 9
^ after defeating Maxentius in 312
^ A partir de derrotar a Maximino Daya
^ After defeating Licinius in 317

References

Barnes, Timothy D. (1984). Constantine and Eusebius. Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-16531-4.
Bowman, Alan (2005). The Cambridge Ancient History Volume 12, The Crisis of Empire, AD 193–337. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-30199-8.
Corcoran, Simon (2000). The Empire of the Tetrarchs, Imperial Pronouncements and Government AD 284–324. Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-815304-X.
Kolb, Frank (1987). Diocletian und die Erste Tetrarchie. Improvisation oder Experiment in der Organisation monarchischer Herrschaft?, Berlin: de Gruyter. ISBN 978-3-11-010934-4
Kuhoff, Wolfgang (2001). Diokletian und die Epoche der Tetrarchie. Das römische Reich zwischen Krisenbewältigung und Neuaufbau (284–313 n. Chr.), Frankfurt am Main: Lang. ISBN 3-631-36792-9
Leadbetter, William Lewis (2009). Galerius and the Will of Diocletian. London and New York: Routledge.
Rees, Roger (2004). Diocletian and the Tetrarchy. Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 0-7486-1661-6.

External links

[1] Historian David Potter translates the term as "gang of four". See idem., Constantine the Emperor (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013), 1.

[2] Qtd. and tr. Leadbetter, Galerius, 3.

[3] Leadbetter, Galerius, 3.

[4] Leadbetter, Galerius, 3–4.

[5] The chronology has been thoroughly established by Kolb, Diocletian, and Kuhoff, Diokletian.

[Constantino-6] ^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h Bajo, F. (1990) Constantino y sus sucesores. La conversión del Imperio. Akal Historia del mundo antiguo, pág 9

[7] ter defeating Maxentius in 312

[8] A partir de derrotar a Maximino Daya

[9] After defeating Licinius in 317

[a]

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]