Jump to content

Lincoln's Lost Speech

Edit links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
"Lost Speech" redirects here. For the speech condition, see Muteness.
This tablet marks the site where Abraham Lincoln delivered his famous "Lost Speech", May 29, 1856. Placed by Leticia Green Stevenson Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution, May 29, 1918.
This plaque marks the site of the Lost Speech.

Lincoln's "Lost Speech" was a speech given by Abraham Lincoln at the Bloomington Convention on May 29, 1856, in Bloomington, Illinois. Traditionally regarded as lost because it was so engaging that reporters neglected to take notes, the speech is believed to have been an impassioned condemnation of slavery.

Speech

[edit]

Lincoln's Lost Speech was given at the since demolished building at the corner of East and Front Streets in downtown Bloomington, Illinois, known as Major's Hall on May 29, 1856.[1] Lincoln gave the speech at the Anti-Nebraska Bloomington Convention that culminated with the founding of the state Republican Party.[1]

In 1856, a then young lawyer, H. C. Whitney, took notes of the speech. After a lapse of forty years, Ida M. Tarbell urged Whitney to publish these notes, which he did, being published in McClure's Magazine for September in 1896. In a book, limited to 500 copies and bound in white boards, the speech was reproduced by the Republican Club of the City of New York as a souvenir for its annual Lincoln Dinner on February 12, 1897. There are no other printings of the speech. Some Lincoln students are skeptical of the Whitney version of this speech with their opinion being that the speech is still lost. Eyewitnesses have offered snippets of some of Lincoln's content that day. William Herndon asserted that some of Lincoln's House Divided Speech was not based on new concepts at the time of its delivery. He wrote that Lincoln's "house divided against itself cannot stand" originated with the famous Bloomington speech of 1856.[2] Editor of the Chicago Tribune Joseph Medill claimed that Chicago lawyer Henry Clay Whitney's transcript of the speech was accurate; Whitney's version was later debunked.[3][4]

It is thought that the speech was a strongly worded derision of slavery.[5][unreliable source?] It is known that Lincoln's condemnation of the expansion of slavery was strong.[6]

The traditional reason given for the lack of any written recollection of the Lost Speech is that Lincoln's skilled and powerful oration had mesmerized every person in attendance. Reporters were said to have laid down their pencils and neglected note taking, as if hypnotized by Lincoln's words. When the speech ended no notes existed, so media reports of the day simply recorded the fact that the speech had been delivered.[4]

There is evidence in Herndon's recollections that the fact that the speech was "lost" may not have been an accident. So strongly worded was Lincoln's oration[7] that others in attendance feared the words might lead to a crumbling of the Union and that Lincoln consented to suspending "its repetition" for the duration of the 1856 campaign.[2]

Whitney version

[edit]

In 1896, Chicago attorney Henry Clay Whitney published his account of the speech in an issue of McClure's Magazine.[8][9] Whitney claimed he had taken notes during the speech and based his version of the speech upon those notes.[9] Initially, Whitney's version was given some credibility. Ida Tarbell sought out Joseph Medill, who was present at the Lost Speech, and he claimed that Whitney's version displayed "remarkable accuracy".[3]

Tarbell was unwittingly carried away by the story, but others were skeptical. Former Lincoln private secretary John George Nicolay declared Whitney's version devoid of Lincoln's style and a fraud.[4] Robert Lincoln, Abraham's son, agreed with Nicolay's assessment.[4] In 1900, the McLean County Historical Society[10] declared their skepticism.[11] In modern times, Lincoln researcher and director of the Chicago Historical Society Paul M. Angle exposed Whitney's version of the speech and his claims of its validity as a "fabrication".[4]

Importance

[edit]

Lincoln's Lost Speech was famous, with a status considered legendary by the time Tarbell became enamored with Whitney's version of it.[4][when?] Lincoln was said to have spoken "like a giant inspired" and the tale of how the speech came to be lost was well known.[4] Many who attended the speech considered it the greatest of Lincoln's life.[12] Given at the first state convention, which essentially founded the Illinois Republican Party, the speech thrust Lincoln into the national political limelight.[6][12]

Though it was known as the Lost Speech, its content influenced people nonetheless. Those who heard it were often asked to repeat what they heard and a frenzied group of supporters spearheaded Lincoln's drive toward a second-place finish among U.S. vice presidential candidates in 1856.[13]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ a b Federal Writer's Project, Illinois: A Descriptive and Historical Guide, (Google Books), A.C. McClurg & Company, Chicago: 1939, p. 164, (ISBN 1603540121).
  2. ^ a b Briggs, John Channing. Lincoln's Speeches Reconsidered, (Google Books), JHU Press, 2005, pp. 165–66, (ISBN 0801881064).
  3. ^ a b Tarbell, Ida M. All In a Day's Work: An Autobiography, (Google Books), 2003, University of Illinois Press, p. 173, (ISBN 0252071360).
  4. ^ a b c d e f g Peterson, Merrill D. Lincoln in American Memory, (Google Books), Oxford University Press, 1994, p. 154, (ISBN 0195096452).
  5. ^ "The Historical Significance of Downtown Bloomington Archived 2008-02-13 at the Wayback Machine", Our History, Downtown Bloomington Association, accessed April 18, 2008.
  6. ^ a b Cima, Greg. "Inspiration found in 'lost speech'[permanent dead link‍]", The Pantagraph (Bloomington, Illinois), May 30, 2006, accessed April 18, 2008.
  7. ^ Carl Sandburg thought that it was similar to a speech, reported in Galena and Springfield newspapers, that Lincoln gave in answer to Millard Fillmore's charge that a Republican victory in 1856 would cause secession: "All this talk about the dissolution of the Union is humbug--nothing but folly. We won't dissolve the Union, and you shan't. [Emphases as given by newspapers.] Sandburg, Carl (1954), Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years, 1965 reprint, New York: Dell, p. 223.
  8. ^ Lincoln, Abraham, Whitney, Henry Clay and Medill, Joseph. "Lincoln's Lost Speech", Now First Published from the Unique Report", (Google Books), McClure's Magazine, S.S. McClure, September 1896, pp. 319–31.
  9. ^ a b Whitney, Henry Clay and Miller, Marion Mills. Life of Lincoln (Google Books), The Baker & Taylor Company, New York: 1908, pp. 327–52.
  10. ^ The location of the speech, Bloomington, Illinois, is found in McLean County.
  11. ^ Prince, Ezra M., ed. Meeting of May 29, 1900 Commemorative of the Convention of May 29, 1856 That Organized the Republican party in the State of Illinois (Transactions of the McLean County Historical Society v. 3) Archived June 10, 2011, at the Wayback Machine, 1900, Abraham Lincoln Historical Digitization Project, Northern Illinois University, accessed April 18, 2008.
  12. ^ a b Angle, Paul M. Abraham Lincoln by Some Men Who Knew Him, (Google Books), Ayer Publishing, 1950, pp. 29–30, (ISBN 083691242X).
  13. ^ Wheeler, Samuel P. "Adultery, Murder and Lincoln", Illinois Times, December 27, 2007, accessed January 27, 2013.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Crissey, Elwell. Lincoln's Lost Speech: The Pivot of His Career, New York: Hawthorn Books, Inc., 1967.
  • Fenster, Julie M. The Case of Abraham Lincoln: A Story of Adultery, Murder, and the Making of a Great President, (Google Books), Palgrave Macmillan, 2007 (ISBN 140397635X).
  • Randall, J. G. "Life on the Circuit with Lincoln by Henry Clay Whitney" JSTOR book review, The American Historical Review, Vol. 46, No. 1 October 1940, pp. 172–173.
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lincoln%27s_Lost_Speech&oldid=1264684600"