Set (music)

Six-element set of rhythmic values used in *Variazioni canoniche* by Luigi Nono^[1]

A set (pitch set, pitch-class set, set class, set form, set genus, pitch collection) in music theory, as in mathematics and general parlance, is a collection of objects. In musical contexts the term is traditionally applied most often to collections of pitches or pitch-classes, but theorists have extended its use to other types of musical entities, so that one may speak of sets of durations or timbres, for example.^[2]

Prime form of five pitch class set from Igor Stravinsky's *In memoriam Dylan Thomas*^[3]

A set by itself does not necessarily possess any additional structure, such as an ordering or permutation. Nevertheless, it is often musically important to consider sets that are equipped with an order relation (called segments); in such contexts, bare sets are often referred to as "unordered", for the sake of emphasis.^[4]

Two-element sets are called dyads, three-element sets trichords (occasionally "triads", though this is easily confused with the traditional meaning of the word triad). Sets of higher cardinalities are called tetrachords (or tetrads), pentachords (or pentads), hexachords (or hexads), heptachords (heptads or, sometimes, mixing Latin and Greek roots, "septachords"),^[5] octachords (octads), nonachords (nonads), decachords (decads), undecachords, and, finally, the dodecachord.

A time-point set is a duration set where the distance in time units between attack points, or time-points, is the distance in semitones between pitch classes.^[6]

Serial

In the theory of serial music, however, some authors^{[weasel words]} (notably Milton Babbitt^[7]^{[page needed]}^{[need quotation to verify]}) use the term "set" where others would use "row" or "series", namely to denote an ordered collection (such as a twelve-tone row) used to structure a work. These authors^{[weasel words]} speak of "twelve tone sets", "time-point sets", "derived sets", etc. (See below.) This is a different usage of the term "set" from that described above (and referred to in the term "set theory").

For these authors,^{[weasel words]} a set form (or row form) is a particular arrangement of such an ordered set: the prime form (original order), inverse (upside down), retrograde (backwards), and retrograde inverse (backwards and upside down).^[2]

A derived set is one which is generated or derived from consistent operations on a subset, for example Webern's Concerto, Op.24, in which the last three subsets are derived from the first:^[8]

${ \override Score.TimeSignature #'stencil = ##f \override Score.SpacingSpanner.strict-note-spacing = ##t \set Score.proportionalNotationDuration = #(ly:make-moment 1/1) \relative c'' { \time 3/1 \set Score.tempoHideNote = ##t \tempo 1 = 60 b1 bes d es, g fis aes e f c' cis a } }$

This can be represented numerically as the integers 0 to 11:

0 11 3 4 8 7 9 5 6 1 2 10

The first subset (B B♭ D) being:

0 11 3 prime-form, interval-string = ⟨−1 +4⟩

The second subset (E♭ G F♯) being the retrograde-inverse of the first, transposed up one semitone:

  3 11 0 retrograde, interval-string = ⟨−4 +1⟩ mod 12
  
  3  7 6 inverse, interval-string = ⟨+4 −1⟩ mod 12
+ 1  1 1
  ------
= 4  8 7

The third subset (G♯ E F) being the retrograde of the first, transposed up (or down) six semitones:

  3 11 0 retrograde
+ 6  6 6
  ------
  9  5 6

And the fourth subset (C C♯ A) being the inverse of the first, transposed up one semitone:

  0 11  3 prime form, interval-vector = ⟨−1 +4⟩ mod 12 

  0  1  9 inverse, interval-string = ⟨+1 −4⟩ mod 12
+ 1  1  1
  -------
  1  2 10

Each of the four trichords (3-note sets) thus displays a relationship which can be made obvious by any of the four serial row operations, and thus creates certain invariances. These invariances in serial music are analogous to the use of common-tones and common-chords in tonal music.^{[citation needed]}

Non-serial

The fundamental concept of a non-serial set is that it is an unordered collection of pitch classes.^[9]

The normal form of a set is the most compact ordering of the pitches in a set.^[10] Tomlin defines the "most compact" ordering as the one where, "the largest of the intervals between any two consecutive pitches is between the first and last pitch listed".^[10] For example, the set (0,2) (a major second) is in normal form while the set (0,10) (a minor seventh, the inversion of a major second) is not, its normal form being (10,0).

Rather than the "original" (untransposed, uninverted) form of the set, the prime form may be considered either the normal form of the set or the normal form of its inversion, whichever is more tightly packed.^[11] Forte (1973) and Rahn (1980) both list the prime forms of a set as the most left-packed possible version of the set. Forte packs from the left and Rahn packs from the right ("making the small numbers smaller," versus making, "the larger numbers ... smaller"^[12]). For many years it was accepted that there were only five instances in which the two algorithms differ.^[13] However, in 2017, music theorist Ian Ring discovered that there is a sixth set class where Forte and Rahn's algorithms arrive at different prime forms.^[14] Ian Ring also established a much simpler algorithm for computing the prime form of a set,^[14] which produces the same results as the more complicated algorithm previously published by John Rahn.

Vectors

References

^ Whittall, Arnold (2008). The Cambridge Introduction to Serialism, p.165. New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-68200-8 (pbk).
^ ^a ^b Wittlich, Gary (1975). "Sets and Ordering Procedures in Twentieth-Century Music", Aspects of Twentieth-Century Music, p.475. Wittlich, Gary (ed.). Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall. ISBN 0-13-049346-5.
^ Whittall (2008), p.127.
^ Morris, Robert (1987). Composition With Pitch-Classes: A Theory of Compositional Design, p.27. Yale University Press. ISBN 0-300-03684-1.
^ E.g., Rahn (1980), 140.
^ Wittlich (1975), p.476.
^ See any of his writings on the twelve-tone system, virtually all of which are reprinted in The Collected Essays of Milton Babbitt, S. Peles et al., eds. Princeton University Press, 2003. ISBN 0-691-08966-3.
^ Wittlich (1975), p.474.
^ John Rahn, Basic Atonal Theory (New York: Longman; London and Toronto: Prentice Hall International, 1980), pp.27–28. ISBN 0-582-28117-2 (Longman); ISBN 0-02-873160-3 (Prentice Hall International). Reprinted 1987 (New York: Schirmer Books; London: Collier Macmillan, 1980), p.27. ISBN 0-02-873160-3.
^ ^a ^b Tomlin, Jay. "All About Set Theory: What is Normal Form?", JayTomlin.com.
^ Tomlin, Jay. "All About Set Theory: What is Prime Form?", JayTomlin.com.
^ Nelson, Paul (2004). "Two Algorithms for Computing the Prime Form". ComposerTools.com. Archived from the original on Dec 23, 2017.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
^ Tsao, Ming (2007). Abstract Musical Intervals: Group Theory for Composition and Analysis, p.99, n.32. ISBN 9781430308355. Algorithms given in Morris, Robert (1991). Class Notes for Atonal Music Theory, p.103. Frog Peak Music.
^ ^a ^b "A study of musical scales by Ian Ring".

External links

"Set Theory Calculator", JayTomlin.com. Calculates normal form, prime form, Forte number, and interval class vector for a given set and vice versa.
"PC Set Calculator", MtA.Ca.

[1] Whittall, Arnold (2008). The Cambridge Introduction to Serialism, p.165. New York: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-68200-8 (pbk).

[Wittlich-2] Wittlich, Gary (1975). "Sets and Ordering Procedures in Twentieth-Century Music", Aspects of Twentieth-Century Music, p.475. Wittlich, Gary (ed.). Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall. ISBN 0-13-049346-5.

[3] Whittall (2008), p.127.

[4] Morris, Robert (1987). Composition With Pitch-Classes: A Theory of Compositional Design, p.27. Yale University Press. ISBN 0-300-03684-1.

[5] E.g., Rahn (1980), 140.

[Wittlich_476-6] Wittlich (1975), p.476.

[7] See any of his writings on the twelve-tone system, virtually all of which are reprinted in The Collected Essays of Milton Babbitt, S. Peles et al., eds. Princeton University Press, 2003. ISBN 0-691-08966-3.

[Wittlich_474-8] Wittlich (1975), p.474.

[9] John Rahn, Basic Atonal Theory (New York: Longman; London and Toronto: Prentice Hall International, 1980), pp.27–28. ISBN 0-582-28117-2 (Longman); ISBN 0-02-873160-3 (Prentice Hall International). Reprinted 1987 (New York: Schirmer Books; London: Collier Macmillan, 1980), p.27. ISBN 0-02-873160-3.

[NF-10] Tomlin, Jay. "All About Set Theory: What is Normal Form?", JayTomlin.com.

[11] Tomlin, Jay. "All About Set Theory: What is Prime Form?", JayTomlin.com.

[Tools-12] Nelson, Paul (2004). "Two Algorithms for Computing the Prime Form". ComposerTools.com. Archived from the original on Dec 23, 2017.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)

[13] Tsao, Ming (2007). Abstract Musical Intervals: Group Theory for Composition and Analysis, p.99, n.32. ISBN 9781430308355. Algorithms given in Morris, Robert (1991). Class Notes for Atonal Music Theory, p.103. Frog Peak Music.

[RingScales-14] "A study of musical scales by Ian Ring".

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

v t e Musical set theory
All-interval tetrachord All-trichord hexachord Complement Forte number Identity Interval class Interval vector Multiplication Permutation Pitch class Pitch interval Pitch-interval class Set List Similarity relation Transformation Z-relation
Diatonic set theory	Bisector Cardinality equals variety Common tone (Deep scale property) Diatonic scale Generated collection Generic and specific intervals (Myhill's property) Maximal evenness Rothenberg propriety Structure implies multiplicity