User talk:Nordenfeldt

Welcome!

Hello, Nordenfeldt, Welcome to Wikipedia!

I hope you like working here and want to continue. If you need help on how to name new articles, look at the Guide to Layout, and for help on formatting the pages visit the Manual of Style. If you need general help, look at Help and the FAQ, and if you can't find your answer there, check the Village Pump (for Wikipedia related questions) or the Reference Desk (for general questions). There's still more help at the Tutorial and the Policy Library. Also, don't forget to visit the Community Portal — and if you have any more questions after that, feel free to post them on my New-Users' Talk Page.

Additional tips:

Here are some extra tips to help you get around Wikipedia:

If you want to play around with your new Wiki skills, try the Sandbox.
Click on the Edit button on a page, and look at how other editors did what they did.
Always give a short explanation of your edits in the edit-summary box.
You can sign your name using four tildes, like this: ~~~~. Always sign comments on Talk pages, never sign Articles.
You might want to add yourself to the New User Log
If your first language isn't English, try Wikipedia:Contributing to articles outside your native language
Full details on Wikipedia style can be found in the Manual of Style.

Happy editing!

--Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 09:46, 15 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Somerville College, Oxford

I commented out the lists because they're not really encyclopædic (note that none of the other articles on Oxbridge colleges have them). I speak as a former MCR president myself, so it's not sour grapes). If any of the people involved is now famous, then mention of that would be appropriate (perhaps in the form of a notation by their name in the lists of notable old members).

Incidentally, note what I say above about "signing" your messages; it makes it much easier to reply to you. --Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 09:46, 15 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Sorry about signing, at the time I did not have an account, now I do.

I suppose its a point that other College do not have it, but then again I'm not sure that should be a deciding factor. None of these people may be famous yet, but a decision was taken inside Somerville to recognise former MCR and JCR preidents, and I thought that decision should be reflected on Wikipedia. It is factually correct, so I apologise but I still don't quoite see why it should not be there. The listing of the current MCR and JCR presients is hardly encyclopedic either, but you do that...

Just my opinion...

Nordenfeldt.

I'm not sure what you mean by the decision being taken in Somerville; recognition in what sense? I think that a case can be made for including the current presidents (though it does lead to difficulties when they change). --Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 13:37, 15 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]

Perhaps I'm not being clear, my bad. Somerville College, as in governing body, asked the MCR to keep trach of former presidents on its webpage. I presume the same was done for the JCR. I just thought there was no reason why this historical data could not also be included here. In the end its your call. I don't really see a good reason why it should not be added, but I don't know this place that well, so I leave it in your hands.

My feeling is that, if it's on the MCR Webpage, to which we link, then that's probably good enough. (Are there really no Somerville JCR/MCR presidents who have become well-known? Perhaps such people were too busy with their studies...

I wonder if my College has done the same; I'll have to check, to make sure they haven't missed me off the list. --Mel Etitis (Μελ Ετητης) 15:06, 15 March 2006 (UTC)[reply]